I pasted the same link for the two screenshots, sorry. Here the correct one:Let me be crystal clear: I'm an astrophyscist and a photographer; I've been there several times and took pictures of the Mount Viso, Superga and the Moon (I also posted some of the results here):The Moon and the basilica each subtend about a half degree, which is consistent with the camera being 82 km from the peak and 11 km from the basilica. Which would make everything in focus with any ordinary camera lens, and give exactly the geometry we see here. Nothing is "magnified", a term that doesn't even have any meaning in this context.
Visto che sei di Torino te lo spiego in italiano; io ho vissuto per anni in pieno centro con vista su Superga; decine di volte ho visto la Luna sorgere da dietro la Basilica, la luna come si sa ha estensione di circa 30' ed è più piccola della Basilica, entrambi questi oggetti sono 'fermi', cioè a uguale distanza sempre. Nessun obiettivo al mondo può mettere a fuoco contemporneamente la Basilica, a pochi km di distanza, il Monviso (3600 mt, ingrandito almeno 10x) che si trova a 64 km. da Torino, e luna ingrandita almeno 10x che si trova a 370.000 km di distanza. E' un fotomontaggio persino ridicolo a cui può credere solo chi non conosce il Piemonte, o non conosce la fotografia, o non conosce la geometria.
Since you're from Turin, I'll explain it to you in Italian; I lived for years in the center with a view of Superga; dozens of times I have seen the Moon rise from behind the Basilica, the moon as we know has an extension of about 30' and is smaller than the Basilica, both of these objects are 'stationary', that is, always at the same distance. No lens in the world can simultaneously focus on the Basilica, a few km away, and Monviso (3600 m, enlarged at least 10x) which is 64 km away. from Turin, and the moon magnified at least 10x which is 370,000 km away. It's an even ridiculous photomontage that only those who don't know Piedmont or don't know photography or don't know geometry can believe.
[img3]https://cosmoedintorni.org/wp-content/u ... erga-2.jpg[/img3]
iframe
Here there are two screenshots taken from PlanIt app, showing the alignment:
[img3]https://cosmoedintorni.org/wp-content/u ... c2023.jpeg[/img3]
[img3]https://cosmoedintorni.org/wp-content/u ... c2023.jpeg[/img3]
To have the Moon larger than Superga you simply have to move further from the basilica: Superga will appear smaller, while the Moon will be still the half degree you correctly wrote.
Statistics: Posted by EmanueleBalboni — Tue Jan 02, 2024 4:40 pm — Replies 37 — Views 5341